My Doctor Said I Have Prediabetes—What Should I Do Now?

My Doctor Said I Have Prediabetes—What Should I Do Now?

Written by Georgios Karanastasis, MD
Board-Certified Internal Medicine Physician & Founder of IASIS Boutique Health

What Prediabetes Means and What to Do After an Elevated A1C

You have routine bloodwork.

Your doctor reviews the results and says:

“Your blood sugar is in the prediabetes range.”

You feel fine.

You do not have diabetes.

You may not have any symptoms at all.

So naturally, you start wondering:

How serious is this?

Does this mean I am going to develop diabetes?

Do I need medication?

Can I bring my numbers back down?

When should my blood sugar be checked again?

Prediabetes means your blood sugar is higher than the normal range but not high enough to meet the criteria for diabetes.

It is not the same as having type 2 diabetes.

But it is an important early warning that your body may not be handling blood sugar as effectively as it once did.

The good news is that prediabetes is exactly the type of health change where early attention can matter.

What Is Prediabetes?

Prediabetes is a state in which blood glucose levels are elevated but have not reached the range used to diagnose diabetes.

It often develops gradually.

Many people have no obvious symptoms.

Prediabetes may be identified through:

  • hemoglobin A1C
  • fasting blood glucose
  • other glucose testing when appropriate

Once it is identified, the goal is to understand why your blood sugar is increasing and reduce the chance that the problem progresses.

What A1C Level Means Prediabetes?

Hemoglobin A1C reflects your average blood sugar over approximately the previous two to three months.

In general:

  • Below 5.7% is generally considered within the normal range
  • 5.7% to 6.4% falls within the prediabetes range
  • 6.5% or higher may meet the laboratory threshold for diabetes

A diagnosis should still be interpreted by your physician in the context of your overall health and other testing.

One number should not be separated from the rest of the patient.

What Does a Fasting Blood Sugar of 100 to 125 Mean?

A fasting glucose between approximately 100 and 125 mg/dL may fall within the impaired fasting glucose or prediabetes range.

A fasting glucose is different from an A1C.

Fasting glucose tells your physician what your blood sugar is at one point in time after fasting.

A1C provides information about your average blood sugar over a longer period.

Your physician may consider both depending on the situation.

Does Prediabetes Mean You Have Diabetes?

No.

This distinction matters.

Prediabetes means your blood sugar is above the normal range, but it has not reached the diagnostic range for diabetes.

It should be taken seriously without assuming that diabetes is inevitable.

Think of prediabetes as an opportunity to intervene earlier.

Does Prediabetes Always Turn Into Type 2 Diabetes?

No.

Some people with prediabetes eventually develop type 2 diabetes.

Others remain stable.

And some improve their blood sugar enough that their measurements return below the prediabetes range.

What happens depends on multiple factors, including:

  • weight
  • physical activity
  • diet
  • family history
  • age
  • sleep
  • medications
  • other metabolic risk factors

This is why follow-up matters.

Can You Have Prediabetes and Feel Completely Normal?

Yes.

Many patients with prediabetes have no symptoms.

That is one reason blood sugar problems are frequently discovered during preventive care rather than because the patient feels sick.

You may exercise, work, travel, and feel completely normal while your A1C is gradually increasing.

Feeling well does not mean the result should be ignored.

But it also does not mean you need to panic.

Why Did My A1C Go Up?

There is not always one single reason.

Your physician may consider:

  • weight gain
  • reduced physical activity
  • family history
  • age
  • dietary patterns
  • sleep quality
  • certain medications
  • other metabolic health conditions

Sometimes the most useful information comes from comparing your current A1C with previous results.

For example, an A1C that gradually moves from 5.3% to 5.6% to 5.9% provides a different story than one isolated result without previous measurements.

Why Does the Trend Matter?

One number provides a snapshot.

A series of numbers can show direction.

Your physician may want to know:

  • Is your A1C stable?
  • Is it gradually increasing?
  • Has it improved?
  • Did the change happen quickly?

This is why continuity and regular review can be valuable.

The goal is not just to label a number as “high.”

The goal is to understand where your health appears to be heading.

What Should You Do First After Being Told You Have Prediabetes?

First, understand your actual numbers.

Ask:

  • What was my A1C?
  • What was my fasting glucose?
  • Have these numbers been rising over time?
  • Do I have other metabolic risk factors?
  • When should the test be repeated?

Then discuss which changes are most realistic and important for you.

Do not leave the appointment with only:

“Watch your sugar.”

You should understand what the actual plan is.

Can Prediabetes Be Reversed?

Blood sugar levels can improve.

Some patients who have an A1C in the prediabetes range later have measurements below that range after changes in weight, diet, activity, or other health factors.

However, I prefer to think about this as improving metabolic health rather than assuming the underlying risk permanently disappears.

If you previously had prediabetes, continued attention to blood sugar and long-term risk remains important even if your numbers improve.

What Lifestyle Change Makes the Biggest Difference?

There is no single perfect intervention for every patient.

The most effective plan is one you can actually continue.

Important areas may include:

  • nutrition
  • physical activity
  • weight management when appropriate
  • sleep
  • reducing prolonged inactivity

Your physician can help identify which area is most relevant for your situation.

Do You Have to Stop Eating Carbohydrates?

No.

A diagnosis of prediabetes does not automatically mean you need to eliminate all carbohydrates.

Carbohydrates differ significantly in nutritional quality and how they affect meals overall.

A more useful approach often involves looking at:

  • portion size
  • added sugars
  • sugary beverages
  • highly refined foods
  • fiber
  • protein
  • overall eating patterns

Extreme diets are not required for every patient with prediabetes.

Do You Have to Stop Eating Fruit?

Not automatically.

Whole fruit is different from drinking large amounts of fruit juice or sweetened beverages.

The overall meal pattern matters.

If you have questions about specific foods, your physician can help determine whether general nutrition changes are enough or whether more individualized nutritional guidance would be useful.

What Foods Should You Reduce With Prediabetes?

For many patients, it is reasonable to look closely at foods and drinks that provide large amounts of rapidly absorbed carbohydrates or added sugar with little nutritional benefit.

Examples may include:

  • sugary soft drinks
  • sweetened coffees
  • energy drinks
  • frequent desserts
  • large portions of highly refined carbohydrates

But the goal should not be perfection.

Sustainable improvement matters more than following an extreme plan for two weeks and then abandoning it.

Does Exercise Help Prediabetes?

Yes.

Physical activity can improve how the body uses glucose and insulin.

A practical exercise plan may include:

  • walking
  • cycling
  • swimming
  • strength training
  • other forms of moderate activity

For many adults, a useful general target is about 150 minutes of moderate physical activity per week when medically appropriate.

If you have been inactive or have heart, joint, balance, or other medical concerns, discuss how to begin safely with your physician.

Does Walking After Meals Help?

It can be a practical way to increase daily activity.

You do not necessarily need a gym membership or intense exercise program to start improving your activity level.

A short walk after meals can be easier to maintain than trying to create one long workout every day.

The best activity plan is usually one that fits realistically into your life.

Does Weight Loss Help Prediabetes?

For patients who have overweight or obesity, even modest weight loss may improve blood sugar regulation and other metabolic risk factors.

You do not need to reach an “ideal” body weight before health improvements can occur.

For some patients, losing roughly 5% to 7% of body weight can produce meaningful metabolic benefits.

The appropriate goal should still be individualized.

What If You Are Not Overweight?

Prediabetes can occur in people who are not overweight.

Weight is only one risk factor.

Your physician may also consider:

  • family history
  • age
  • activity level
  • body composition
  • medications
  • other metabolic conditions

If you are already at a healthy weight, the plan should not simply be “lose weight.”

Your physician should look at the rest of the picture.

Does Family History Matter With Prediabetes?

Yes.

A parent or sibling with type 2 diabetes may increase your own risk.

Tell your physician:

  • who in the family has diabetes
  • approximately when they developed it
  • whether several relatives are affected

If you are unsure what other family information matters, read what family medical history you should tell your doctor.

Can Poor Sleep Affect Blood Sugar?

Sleep is part of metabolic health.

Consistently poor sleep may affect appetite, activity, weight, and how the body regulates glucose.

Tell your physician if you:

  • sleep poorly most nights
  • snore heavily
  • wake feeling unrefreshed
  • experience significant daytime sleepiness

Those issues may deserve attention alongside nutrition and exercise.

Can Stress Affect Blood Sugar?

Stress can influence sleep, eating patterns, activity, and metabolic health.

It should not be treated as the only explanation for an elevated A1C, but it can be one part of the broader picture.

If stress has significantly changed your sleep, appetite, activity, or weight, tell your physician.

Can Medications Increase Blood Sugar?

Some medications can influence blood glucose.

If your A1C changed significantly after a medication was started or adjusted, bring that timeline to your physician's attention.

Do not stop a prescription medication on your own.

Your doctor can review whether the medication may be contributing and whether the benefits still outweigh the metabolic effect.

If you take several medications, read what to ask your doctor when your medication list keeps getting longer.

Do You Need Medication for Prediabetes?

Not everyone with prediabetes needs medication.

For many patients, lifestyle intervention and monitoring are the initial approach.

Medication may be considered in selected patients based on factors such as:

  • how elevated the blood sugar is
  • age
  • weight
  • overall metabolic risk
  • previous gestational diabetes
  • other individual risk factors

The decision should be individualized rather than based solely on the word “prediabetes.”

Does Prediabetes Mean You Need a GLP-1 Medication?

No.

Prediabetes alone does not automatically mean a GLP-1 medication is necessary.

Those medications may be considered in certain patients for specific indications, including weight management or diabetes treatment, depending on the individual's health situation.

Medication decisions should take into account:

  • weight
  • blood sugar
  • other medical conditions
  • risks
  • benefits
  • long-term treatment goals

IASIS discusses these medications separately in our guide to GLP-1 weight-loss medications and medical follow-up.

How Often Should A1C Be Rechecked?

The appropriate schedule depends on the individual.

Your physician may consider:

  • your current A1C
  • how quickly the number changed
  • previous results
  • whether you are making lifestyle changes
  • whether medication is involved
  • other metabolic risk factors

Ask before leaving the appointment:

“When do you want to check my A1C again?”

Prediabetes should not simply be added to your chart and forgotten.

What If Your A1C Is 5.7 or 5.8?

That is at the lower end of the prediabetes range.

It does not mean the result should be ignored.

But it also does not mean you should assume diabetes is imminent.

Your physician may look closely at:

  • previous A1C results
  • fasting glucose
  • weight trends
  • family history
  • overall metabolic risk

The direction of the trend can matter as much as the isolated number.

What If Your A1C Is 6.3 or 6.4?

An A1C near the upper end of the prediabetes range deserves careful follow-up because it is closer to the laboratory threshold used for diabetes.

Your physician may want to:

  • review previous results
  • repeat testing at an appropriate interval
  • review fasting glucose
  • discuss more intensive lifestyle changes
  • consider whether medication is appropriate

The exact plan depends on the patient.

What If One Test Says Prediabetes but Another Is Normal?

This can happen.

A1C and fasting glucose measure blood sugar differently.

If results do not match, your physician may need to:

  • review previous tests
  • repeat testing
  • consider factors that could affect the measurements
  • interpret the results in the context of your overall health

Do not try to diagnose yourself based on whichever number looks better or worse.

What If Your A1C Was High Once and Normal the Next Time?

That can be encouraging.

But your physician may still want to understand:

  • why the number changed
  • whether your weight changed
  • whether your diet or exercise changed
  • whether medication affected the result

If you previously had prediabetes, continued periodic monitoring may still be appropriate even when your A1C improves.

Can Prediabetes Cause Fatigue?

Sometimes blood sugar changes may occur alongside fatigue, but fatigue has many possible causes.

Do not automatically assume prediabetes explains persistent exhaustion.

If fatigue is a major problem, your physician may need to evaluate it separately.

Read when persistent fatigue should be evaluated by a doctor.

Does Prediabetes Cause Increased Thirst or Frequent Urination?

Many people with prediabetes have no symptoms.

Significant thirst and frequent urination can occur when blood sugar becomes more elevated and should be discussed with your physician.

If those symptoms are new or worsening, do not simply wait until the next annual physical.

Can Prediabetes Affect Your Heart?

Prediabetes often occurs alongside other cardiovascular risk factors.

Your physician may also review:

  • blood pressure
  • cholesterol
  • weight
  • smoking history
  • family history
  • physical activity

The goal is not just preventing a higher A1C.

It is improving the overall metabolic and cardiovascular risk picture.

What If You Also Have High Cholesterol or High Blood Pressure?

This makes looking at the whole patient even more important.

Prediabetes, high blood pressure, high cholesterol, and excess weight can occur together.

Treating them as completely separate problems may miss the broader metabolic picture.

Your physician can help determine which changes may improve several risk factors at once.

This broader approach is part of chronic disease management in Orland Park.

What If You Lost Weight and Your A1C Improved?

That is encouraging.

Your doctor may want you to continue the habits that helped.

The goal should be sustainable long-term health rather than repeatedly losing and regaining weight.

You may still need periodic monitoring to make sure the improvement continues.

Do You Need to Check Your Blood Sugar at Home?

Not everyone with prediabetes needs home glucose monitoring.

Your physician can determine whether home checks would provide useful information in your specific situation.

For many patients with uncomplicated prediabetes, periodic laboratory monitoring may be more useful than checking blood sugar multiple times every day.

Should You Buy a Continuous Glucose Monitor for Prediabetes?

Not automatically.

Continuous glucose monitors can provide a large amount of information, but more data does not always create better decisions.

Before using one, ask:

  • What question are we trying to answer?
  • How will the information change my plan?
  • Do I actually need this level of monitoring?

Technology should support medical decision-making rather than create unnecessary anxiety over every glucose fluctuation.

What If You Are Afraid to Eat After Being Diagnosed With Prediabetes?

Prediabetes should not make you afraid of food.

The goal is to improve overall eating patterns, not create an unhealthy relationship with eating.

Most patients do not need to eliminate entire food groups.

A sustainable plan is usually more useful than an extreme plan.

What If Your Doctor Just Said “Watch Your Diet”?

Ask for more information.

You can say:

“What specifically would you like me to change?”

And:

“When should we recheck my A1C?”

You should leave knowing what you are trying to accomplish.

If the plan is simply to monitor the number, our guide to what it means when your doctor says “let’s monitor it” may help you understand what a real follow-up plan should include.

What Questions Should You Ask Your Doctor About Prediabetes?

Consider asking:

  • What was my A1C?
  • How does it compare with my previous results?
  • Do I actually meet the criteria for prediabetes?
  • What are my biggest risk factors?
  • What changes would make the biggest difference for me?
  • Should I lose weight?
  • Do I need medication?
  • When should my A1C be checked again?
  • Are my cholesterol and blood pressure also where they should be?

Why Primary Care Is a Good Place to Manage Prediabetes

Prediabetes does not exist in isolation.

Your physician may need to look at:

  • blood sugar
  • blood pressure
  • cholesterol
  • weight
  • medications
  • family history
  • physical activity
  • sleep

That broader perspective is part of adult primary care in Orland Park and internal medicine in Orland Park.

How IASIS Boutique Health Approaches Prediabetes

At IASIS Boutique Health in Orland Park, Georgios Karanastasis, MD, provides membership-based adult primary care and internal medicine through a limited-panel practice.

When a patient's A1C enters the prediabetes range, the goal is not simply to highlight the number in the chart.

The result should be understood within the patient's broader metabolic and cardiovascular health.

Depending on the individual patient, that may include reviewing:

  • previous A1C and glucose results
  • weight trends
  • blood pressure
  • cholesterol
  • family history
  • medications
  • nutrition
  • physical activity
  • sleep

A follow-up plan can then be created based on the patient's actual risk rather than treating every prediabetes result exactly the same.

For adults who want more time to understand their laboratory trends and long-term metabolic health, learn more about concierge primary care at IASIS Boutique Health.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an A1C of 5.7 prediabetes?

An A1C from 5.7% through 6.4% generally falls within the laboratory range used for prediabetes. Your physician should interpret the result alongside your other health information.

Can prediabetes go back to normal?

Yes. Some patients improve their blood sugar enough that later measurements fall below the prediabetes range. Continued attention to metabolic health is still important because the underlying risk may remain.

Does prediabetes always become diabetes?

No. Prediabetes increases the risk of developing type 2 diabetes, but progression is not inevitable. Weight, activity, nutrition, family history, and other factors influence risk.

Do I need medication for prediabetes?

Not necessarily. Many patients begin with lifestyle changes and monitoring. Medication may be considered for selected patients depending on their overall risk.

How often should A1C be checked if I have prediabetes?

The appropriate interval depends on your current result, previous trends, risk factors, and treatment plan. Ask your physician when they want the test repeated rather than assuming it will wait until your next annual physical.

Can I eat carbohydrates if I have prediabetes?

Yes. Prediabetes does not automatically require eliminating all carbohydrates. Portion size, food quality, fiber, added sugars, and the overall eating pattern matter.

Can thin people get prediabetes?

Yes. Prediabetes can occur in people who are not overweight. Family history, age, activity, medications, and other metabolic factors can also play a role.

Should I check my blood sugar every day if I have prediabetes?

Not everyone with prediabetes needs daily home glucose testing. Your physician can determine whether it would provide useful information in your situation.

What is the most important thing to do after a prediabetes diagnosis?

Understand your actual A1C and glucose results, review your risk factors with your physician, make realistic lifestyle changes when appropriate, and establish a clear plan for when your blood sugar will be checked again.

The Bottom Line

Prediabetes is not diabetes.

And it is not a guarantee that you will eventually develop diabetes.

But it is information worth acting on.

After being told you have prediabetes, make sure you understand:

What was my A1C?

Has it been increasing?

What risk factors do I have?

What changes should I make?

Do I need medication?

When do we check it again?

The best time to address rising blood sugar is before it becomes more difficult to manage.

At IASIS Boutique Health, Dr. Georgios Karanastasis provides adult primary care in Orland Park through a limited-panel membership model centered on preventive medicine, longer appointments, laboratory trend review, chronic-condition management, and direct physician communication.

About the Author

Georgios Karanastasis, MD is a board-certified internal medicine physician and founder of IASIS Boutique Health in Orland Park, Illinois. He earned his medical degree from the University of Athens in Greece and completed his internal medicine residency at John H. Stroger Jr. Hospital of Cook County.

Dr. Karanastasis provides adult primary care with a focus on preventive medicine, cardiovascular health, medication management, chronic disease management, and long-term physician-patient relationships.

Through IASIS Boutique Health, he provides membership-based care through a limited-panel practice designed to allow longer appointments, direct physician communication, continuity, and more time to understand each patient's broader health picture.

Medical Review: Georgios Karanastasis, MD
Last Reviewed: November 2, 2026

Medical Disclaimer

This article is intended for general educational purposes only and does not replace individualized medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Blood sugar results should be interpreted by a qualified healthcare professional in the context of your medical history, medications, symptoms, and other test results. Do not start, stop, or change prescription medication based solely on information in this article.